Tony Gilroy: Star Wars Should Resist the 'Toy Box' Impulse

Tony Gilroy, the creator behind Andor and Rogue One, urged franchise storytellers to resist the urge "to open the toy box and start playing with all the toys," arguing they should leave more toys in the box and add to the world rather than take from it. He made the comments on a podcast with Backstory Magazine, and presented Andor as an example of a restrained, mature series that felt focused amid a surge of Star Wars shows on Disney+.

The contrast is clear in recent Disney-era entries. Series such as The Book of Boba Fett, Obi-Wan Kenobi and Ahsoka often felt overindulgent and messy, while the Mandoverse leaned heavily on legacy characters — Boba Fett, Bo-Katan, Ahsoka and Luke Skywalker — a tendency Gilroy’s remark critiques as playing with childhood toys rather than shaping new stories.

Gilroy framed his approach as a way to recover what made the original films resonate: grounded conflict and political subtext.

tony gilroy, andor, rogue one, star wars, disney+, mandoverse, obi-wan kenobi, ahsoka, legacy characters, political subtext